OpenAI
1068 Elo ±44
Rank #16 of 45 · median 37s per image · 11 refused
Not judged in the same call yet
Elo expectation: GPT Image 1.5 wins 24%
OpenAI
1264 Elo ±37
Rank #3 of 45 · median 126s per image · 12 refused

By category

CategoryGPT Image 1.5GPT Image 2Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 1116 1294 —
Architecture & Interiors 1110 1415 —
Complex Scenes 1011 1363 —
Ghibli style 1169 1336 —
Graphic Design 924 1229 —
Hands & Anatomy 1087 1120 —
Photorealistic People & Portraits 1080 1296 —
Surreal & Creative Prompts 1131 1330 —
Text in Images 991 1217 —
Ultra Hard 1242 1319 —

By criterion

CriterionGPT Image 1.5GPT Image 2
Prompt adherence 1118 1216
Technical quality 1009 1209
Artistic merit 1060 1161
Detail execution 1050 1240
Realism & coherence 982 1211

Side by side

A magical girl character in a frilly dress, casting a spell (classic anime trope). - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 5th of 13, this offers excellent prompt fulfillment and considerable visual appeal. Overcrowding and uneven resolution of the glove and ruffles make it less polished than its initial sparkle suggests.
A magical girl character in a frilly dress, casting a spell (classic anime trope). - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks fourth as a highly accomplished and strongly adherent magical-girl illustration. Slightly strained hand proportions and dense visual layering place it just behind the leading images.
Cutaway architectural drawing of a traditional Japanese machiya townhouse showing all rooms and structural elements. Include accurate proportions, traditional joinery, and typical spatial organization. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 5 / 10
Judge's noteThe image is more engaging and programmatically rich than the minimal room cutaways. Nevertheless, its covered courtyard, unresolved upper access, and unreliable annotations significantly weaken its architectural credibility.
Cutaway architectural drawing of a traditional Japanese machiya townhouse showing all rooms and structural elements. Include accurate proportions, traditional joinery, and typical spatial organization. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 3rd of 12 because of its exceptional breadth and convincing townhouse proportions. Terminology errors and inconsistencies between numbered spaces and supporting drawings keep it below the two strongest entries.
A bustling market scene with dozens of people buying and selling goods. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 6 / 10
Judge's noteVivid and highly faithful to the prompt, but weaker on the close-up interaction that should anchor the scene. The ambiguous weighing apparatus and soft hand structure outweigh its attractive atmosphere.
A bustling market scene with dozens of people buying and selling goods. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked second, with particularly strong documentary realism and sustained crowd complexity. It narrowly trails the first image because its visual hierarchy is less controlled, not because it lacks market activity.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 7th of 13: this is a lively and richly populated interpretation with clear gardening activity. Its crowded staging, coarse highlights, and minor botanical and contact ambiguities keep it below the more controlled illustrations.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 3rd of 12, this is one of the strongest interpretations of shared gardening and affectionate supervision. It falls just below the leaders because its tonal separation and focal refinement are slightly less polished.
Abstract geometric logo for tech startup 'Quantum Leap', evoking connection & speed, vibrant blue/purple gradient, sharp angles. 'Quantum Leap' as text contained in logo. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 11th of 13: correct wording keeps it above the misspelled and severely cropped candidates. Poor text contrast and excessive rendered complexity significantly undermine its core function as a logo.
Abstract geometric logo for tech startup 'Quantum Leap', evoking connection & speed, vibrant blue/purple gradient, sharp angles. 'Quantum Leap' as text contained in logo. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 1st of 12, this offers the strongest balance of prompt accuracy, readability, motion, and connectivity. Its controlled geometry and integrated wordmark make it the most convincing finished logo in the set.
A hand drawing a sketch on paper with a pencil, the hand and pencil tip in clear focus. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 4th of 13, this is one of the strongest images for the explicitly requested close-focus detail. Its restricted framing and slightly exaggerated graphite point keep it below the more complete leading compositions.
A hand drawing a sketch on paper with a pencil, the hand and pencil tip in clear focus. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanked last because the apparent extra finger critically undermines a prompt centered on convincing finger positioning and object interaction. Attractive materials and a competent sketch cannot compensate for that anatomical failure.
A ultra high-resolution portrait of an elderly woman with silver hair and bifocal glasses, each lens reflecting a distant landscape, captured in warm late-afternoon sunlight - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 6 / 10
Judge's noteRank 7 of 13: this is visually arresting and richly detailed, but weaker in physical optics. The postcard-like reflections and absent visible bifocal segments substantially limit its realism and prompt accuracy.
A ultra high-resolution portrait of an elderly woman with silver hair and bifocal glasses, each lens reflecting a distant landscape, captured in warm late-afternoon sunlight - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 2nd of 12, this is among the most photographically convincing images in the set. It narrowly trails the leader because its landscape reflections are less clear and visually distinctive.
A waterfall that pours out stars and galaxies instead of water, illustrated in a cosmic fantasy style with vibrant space colors and dramatic lighting effects. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 6 / 10
Judge's noteRank 9 of 13. The prompt is fulfilled directly and the impact is dramatic. Excessive particle density, flattened depth, and an overbright base materially reduce the quality of execution.
A waterfall that pours out stars and galaxies instead of water, illustrated in a cosmic fantasy style with vibrant space colors and dramatic lighting effects. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks first for the clearest integration of galaxies into genuinely flowing material. It combines exceptionally strong prompt adherence with controlled composition, convincing depth, and detailed execution.
A book cover showing the title "Journey to Mars" along with an astronaut illustration, contemporary sci-fi design style. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 4 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks last because elaborate rendering cannot compensate for visibly cropping the required title. The defect directly compromises the task's emphasis on accurate, clear text integrated with imagery.
A book cover showing the title "Journey to Mars" along with an astronaut illustration, contemporary sci-fi design style. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked second of twelve: this is a highly polished and convincing publishing mockup. Only minor title-background blending and the conventional planetary montage separate it from the strongest entry.
Photorealistic close-up portrait of a person clearly performing the American Sign Language gesture for "thank you," hand positioned visibly in front of the chest, clear expression on face, neutral background - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 9 / 10
Judge's noteThis provides the strongest combination of recognizable sign positioning, anatomical clarity, and photographic polish. It ranks first because the gesture and expression are especially easy to read together.
Photorealistic close-up portrait of a person clearly performing the American Sign Language gesture for "thank you," hand positioned visibly in front of the chest, clear expression on face, neutral background - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 11th of 12, this is a believable portrait of a different gesture. The incorrect sign, loose framing, and comparatively plain presentation substantially limit its success.

More comparisons