OpenAI
1068 Elo ±44
Rank #16 of 45 · median 37s per image · 11 refused
28–13–43
wins – ties – losses for GPT Image 1.5
84 direct comparisons
Elo expectation: GPT Image 1.5 wins 43%
Microsoft
1115 Elo ±42
Rank #12 of 45 · median 69s per image · 15 refused

By category

CategoryGPT Image 1.5MAI-Image-2.6Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 1116 1266 0–2–4
Architecture & Interiors 1110 1098 3–3–3
Complex Scenes 1011 1072 3–1–5
Ghibli style 1169 1486 0–0–1
Graphic Design 924 1055 3–1–6
Hands & Anatomy 1087 1094 4–2–3
Photorealistic People & Portraits 1080 1049 5–1–4
Surreal & Creative Prompts 1131 1233 2–1–7
Text in Images 991 1085 3–0–7
Ultra Hard 1242 1206 5–2–3

By criterion

CriterionGPT Image 1.5MAI-Image-2.6
Prompt adherence 1118 1088
Technical quality 1009 1068
Artistic merit 1060 1121
Detail execution 1050 1092
Realism & coherence 982 1083

Side by side

An anime scene of a character eating ramen at a small shop counter (slice-of-life style). - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 7 / 10
Judge's noteThis is a lively, appealing interpretation with excellent prompt coverage but less controlled focal detail than the top four. It ranks 5th of 13 because the busy staging and slightly unclear utensil overlaps prevent an excellent overall rating.
An anime scene of a character eating ramen at a small shop counter (slice-of-life style). - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 10 / 10
Judge's noteRanks first for combining excellent character depiction with the most persuasive everyday atmosphere. It reads as finished professional illustration, with no conspicuous anatomical, spatial, or object-interaction defects.
A photorealistic interior of a modern Scandinavian-style living room with natural light streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows. Show detailed wood textures, fabric materials, and proper light reflections. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 6th of 13, this image excels in tactile richness and warm Scandinavian character. A denser arrangement and mildly idealized textile rendering place it below the most photographically convincing interiors.
A photorealistic interior of a modern Scandinavian-style living room with natural light streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows. Show detailed wood textures, fabric materials, and proper light reflections. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 11th of 12 because its softer material rendering noticeably limits the requested photorealism. The design and atmosphere are successful, but close inspection reveals a substantial gap from the leaders.
A family cooking together in a kitchen, each person busy with a different task. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 4th of 13 thanks to excellent task coverage and convincingly integrated preparation details. It narrowly misses the top tier because its synchronized expressions and polished staging feel less spontaneous.
A family cooking together in a kitchen, each person busy with a different task. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 6 / 10
Judge's noteThe image is attractive and mostly on-prompt, but a prominent task interaction is insufficiently convincing. Because accurate hand-tool-food relationships are central to this evaluation, that weakness carries more weight than the decorative richness.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 7th of 13: this is a lively and richly populated interpretation with clear gardening activity. Its crowded staging, coarse highlights, and minor botanical and contact ambiguities keep it below the more controlled illustrations.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 4th of 12, this is a strong, coherent illustration with excellent vegetable rendering and warm characterization. It ranks below the leading shared-harvest scenes because its interaction and compositional emphasis are slightly less distinctive.
Set of 5 consistent flat design icons for a mobile banking app: 'Home', 'Transfer', 'Account', 'Scan QR', 'Settings'. Monochrome dark blue. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 4 / 10
Judge's noteComplete concept coverage is undermined by severe presentation problems. Poor contrast and non-flat rendering outweigh the correct labels and recognizable symbols.
Set of 5 consistent flat design icons for a mobile banking app: 'Home', 'Transfer', 'Account', 'Scan QR', 'Settings'. Monochrome dark blue. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 4th of 12, this is a strong and usable outline set. Its slightly looser geometry and more abstract scan detail distinguish it from the two leading examples.
A person typing on a laptop keyboard, showing both hands on the keys. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 1st of 13, this image best addresses the core test of realistic anatomy and interaction. Small device-label imperfections prevent a flawless score, but its hands and contact are exceptionally convincing.
A person typing on a laptop keyboard, showing both hands on the keys. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 3 / 10
Judge's noteThis is the weakest image because a critical extra-hand error defeats the central realism test. Competent lighting and textures do not compensate for the scene's anatomical incoherence.
A hyper-realistic photo of a toddler with curly hair and big eyes, looking upward. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 9 / 10
Judge's noteAmong the strongest close-up portraits, with exceptional facial detail and an immediately readable upward gaze. Slight eye idealization and tight framing are its only meaningful limitations.
A hyper-realistic photo of a toddler with curly hair and big eyes, looking upward. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanks tenth as a competent portrait with clear prompt coverage. The conspicuously processed face is a more important limitation than its otherwise successful setting and composition.
The Mona Lisa reimagined as a futuristic android, rendered in a digital art style that preserves Da Vinci's composition while incorporating sleek cyberpunk aesthetics and technological elements. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks eighth because it is a competent futuristic portrait but only a partial preservation of the specified composition. The generic combat armor and interrupted hand framing are substantial prompt-level weaknesses.
The Mona Lisa reimagined as a futuristic android, rendered in a digital art style that preserves Da Vinci's composition while incorporating sleek cyberpunk aesthetics and technological elements. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 4th of 12 for its elaborate construction and distinctive veiled interpretation. It is slightly less restrained and immediately legible than the higher-ranked portraits, particularly around the illuminated eye.
A wrinkled white T-shirt with "Carpe Diem" in bold serif font and "Seize The Day" in smaller script below it, modeled on a mannequin, professional product photography with soft-box lighting. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 2nd of 13, this is an excellent and highly faithful product image. Its slightly pristine print treatment gives the top-ranked entry an advantage in fabric–text integration.
A wrinkled white T-shirt with "Carpe Diem" in bold serif font and "Seize The Day" in smaller script below it, modeled on a mannequin, professional product photography with soft-box lighting. - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 4 / 10
Judge's noteCredible cloth and mannequin rendering cannot repair the missing 'Diem'. Because accurate text is a primary purpose of the prompt, this substantive omission makes it the weakest overall result.
Photorealistic image of a robot painting a realistic self-portrait (i.e. the robot) on canvas, mimicking Van Gogh’s art style; clear, realistic metallic textures and painting details visible - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 5 / 10
Judge's noteMore imaginative and self-portrait-aware than the human-portrait variants, but it fails the photorealistic outer-scene requirement. Its high painterly merit cannot compensate for that central stylistic mismatch.
Photorealistic image of a robot painting a realistic self-portrait (i.e. the robot) on canvas, mimicking Van Gogh’s art style; clear, realistic metallic textures and painting details visible - MAI-Image-2.6
MAI-Image-2.6 9 / 10
Judge's noteAn excellent and complete interpretation with strong likeness, convincing materials, and a believable studio setting. Slightly over-explanatory staging and the sculptural appearance of parts of the painted face prevent it from leading the set.

More comparisons