OpenAI
1068 Elo ±44
Rank #16 of 45 · median 37s per image · 11 refused
Not judged in the same call yet
Elo expectation: GPT Image 1.5 wins 28%
XAI
1228 Elo ±38
Rank #5 of 45 · median 25s per image · 1 refused

By category

CategoryGPT Image 1.5Grok Imagine 2.0Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 1116 1195 —
Architecture & Interiors 1110 1282 —
Complex Scenes 1011 1378 —
Ghibli style 1169 1185 —
Graphic Design 924 1256 —
Hands & Anatomy 1087 1134 —
Photorealistic People & Portraits 1080 1243 —
Surreal & Creative Prompts 1131 1243 —
Text in Images 991 1181 —
Ultra Hard 1242 1372 —

By criterion

CriterionGPT Image 1.5Grok Imagine 2.0
Prompt adherence 1118 1180
Technical quality 1009 1196
Artistic merit 1060 1144
Detail execution 1050 1206
Realism & coherence 982 1191

Side by side

A Looney Tunes-inspired cartoon scene of a clever rabbit tricking a hunter. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 1st of 12 for the strongest combination of recognizable cartoon humor, clear deception, and polished execution. Its minor staging ambiguity does not substantially weaken the central gag.
A Looney Tunes-inspired cartoon scene of a clever rabbit tricking a hunter. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks fifth because its polished illustration cannot fully compensate for the missing visible trick. It works better as a conversation preceding a gag than as a complete response to the prompt.
Aerial view of a modernist desert home, in the style of Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater but adapted to desert conditions. Show integration with rocky landscape and water features. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanks third: one of the clearest and most visually compelling desert reinterpretations of Fallingwater. Slightly synthetic water and rock treatment leaves it below the two more convincing architectural images.
Aerial view of a modernist desert home, in the style of Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater but adapted to desert conditions. Show integration with rocky landscape and water features. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks sixth, with a strong ecological concept but a less resolved finished image. Ambiguous waterworks and compressed architectural detail hold it below the more clearly articulated upper group.
An underwater scene with scuba divers exploring a coral reef alongside colorful fish and a sunken ship. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 6th of 13, this image stands out for marine diversity and active exploration. Its grainy finish and occasionally muddled wreck geometry keep it below the cleaner, more convincing leaders.
An underwater scene with scuba divers exploring a coral reef alongside colorful fish and a sunken ship. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked second of twelve, this is the strongest entry for photographic coherence and natural underwater atmosphere. It offers slightly less spectacular species variety than the winner, but its believable divers and integrated lighting are exceptional.
A flying castle floating in clouds at sunrise. Match the visual aesthetic of 'Howl's Moving Castle' by Studio Ghibli, with Miyazaki's blend of steampunk elements and fantasy. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 9 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks first of the 12 images for its balance of stylistic fidelity, imaginative engineering, and clear composition. Minor ambiguity in the smallest mechanisms keeps it below a flawless score.
A flying castle floating in clouds at sunrise. Match the visual aesthetic of 'Howl's Moving Castle' by Studio Ghibli, with Miyazaki's blend of steampunk elements and fantasy. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 7th of 10, this succeeds at monumental atmosphere more than expressive mechanical design. Its crowded, weakly differentiated industrial detail prevents the quantity of information from translating into equally strong visual clarity.
Set of 5 consistent flat design icons for a mobile banking app: 'Home', 'Transfer', 'Account', 'Scan QR', 'Settings'. Monochrome dark blue. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 4 / 10
Judge's noteComplete concept coverage is undermined by severe presentation problems. Poor contrast and non-flat rendering outweigh the correct labels and recognizable symbols.
Set of 5 consistent flat design icons for a mobile banking app: 'Home', 'Transfer', 'Account', 'Scan QR', 'Settings'. Monochrome dark blue. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 1st of 12, this offers the strongest combination of exact adherence, legibility, and family consistency. Its disciplined execution most closely resembles a professionally prepared banking navigation set.
A person typing on a laptop keyboard, showing both hands on the keys. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 1st of 13, this image best addresses the core test of realistic anatomy and interaction. Small device-label imperfections prevent a flawless score, but its hands and contact are exceptionally convincing.
A person typing on a laptop keyboard, showing both hands on the keys. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteThis is a polished-looking image whose close crop exposes noticeable hand-modeling weaknesses. It fulfills the scene request but is only moderately successful at the specific realism test.
A nighttime portrait of a man lit by neon signs on a city street. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 6 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks tenth because surface processing weakens an otherwise effective composition. It satisfies the prompt, but the central portrait is less photographically convincing than its sharpness initially suggests.
A nighttime portrait of a man lit by neon signs on a city street. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 9 / 10
Judge's noteThis is a close second to the ramen-sign portrait, with especially convincing photographic restraint and facial rendering. Its balance of expression, lighting, and environmental depth is substantially stronger than the middle-ranked entries.
A city skyline that forms the shape of musical notes on a staff, created in a stylized graphic design aesthetic with clean architectural lines and dramatic twilight colors. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 4th for its expressive color and convincing graphic synthesis of music and architecture. Crowded overlaps and incomplete transformation of the skyline keep it below the more precise leading images.
A city skyline that forms the shape of musical notes on a staff, created in a stylized graphic design aesthetic with clean architectural lines and dramatic twilight colors. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 8th of 12 because its graphic style fits well, but the symbolic integration remains incomplete. It is more prompt-aligned than the naturalistic gold-outline overlay, though less inventive than the skyline-as-score interpretation.
A book cover showing the title "Journey to Mars" along with an astronaut illustration, contemporary sci-fi design style. - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 4 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks last because elaborate rendering cannot compensate for visibly cropping the required title. The defect directly compromises the task's emphasis on accurate, clear text integrated with imagery.
A book cover showing the title "Journey to Mars" along with an astronaut illustration, contemporary sci-fi design style. - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked third of twelve: this is among the strongest designs for typographic hierarchy and visual discipline. Minor author-text interference and somewhat conventional environmental imagery keep it below the top two.
Photorealistic image of a robot painting a realistic self-portrait (i.e. the robot) on canvas, mimicking Van Gogh’s art style; clear, realistic metallic textures and painting details visible - GPT Image 1.5
GPT Image 1.5 5 / 10
Judge's noteMore imaginative and self-portrait-aware than the human-portrait variants, but it fails the photorealistic outer-scene requirement. Its high painterly merit cannot compensate for that central stylistic mismatch.
Photorealistic image of a robot painting a realistic self-portrait (i.e. the robot) on canvas, mimicking Van Gogh’s art style; clear, realistic metallic textures and painting details visible - Grok Imagine 2.0
Grok Imagine 2.0 9 / 10
Judge's noteThis is the strongest overall result, combining a recognizable robot self-portrait with convincing painting action and excellent material separation. Its slightly hyper-detailed finish keeps it just short of completely natural photographic perfection.

More comparisons