OpenAI
760 Elo ±58
Rank #40 of 45 · median 19s per image
41–22–35
wins – ties – losses for DALL-E 3
98 direct comparisons
Elo expectation: DALL-E 3 wins 55%
Midjourney
725 Elo ±38
Rank #41 of 45 · median 34s per image · 2 refused

By category

CategoryDALL-E 3Midjourney V6.1Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 1029 793 7–2–1
Architecture & Interiors 671 778 1–4–5
Complex Scenes 569 600 5–1–4
Ghibli style 752 733 3–2–3
Graphic Design 968 719 8–2–0
Hands & Anatomy 708 703 3–2–5
Photorealistic People & Portraits 483 727 1–2–7
Surreal & Creative Prompts 871 639 6–3–1
Text in Images 617 743 2–2–6
Ultra Hard 607 634 5–2–3

By criterion

CriterionDALL-E 3Midjourney V6.1
Prompt adherence 793 723
Technical quality 876 817
Artistic merit 991 903
Detail execution 839 764
Realism & coherence 757 797

Side by side

A 90s anime-style space battle scene with giant starships and laser beams. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 4 / 10
Judge's noteThe weakest interpretation of the requested scene, despite abundant visual detail and strong color spectacle. Its dominant robot, non-cel rendering, and unclear mechanical relationships are substantial shortcomings rather than minor polish issues.
A 90s anime-style space battle scene with giant starships and laser beams. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 7 / 10
Judge's noteAn artistically excellent anime dogfight, but a less complete interpretation of a giant-starship battle. Its scale ambiguity and occasional structural looseness keep it below the leading capital-ship scenes.
Aerial view of a modernist desert home, in the style of Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater but adapted to desert conditions. Show integration with rocky landscape and water features. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 12th of 12, this has sculptural appeal but the least convincing combination of environmental scale, fine detail, and architectural-water integration. Repetitive terrain and distorted furnishings substantially reduce its otherwise competent presentation.
Aerial view of a modernist desert home, in the style of Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater but adapted to desert conditions. Show integration with rocky landscape and water features. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 6th of 12, this is attractive and substantially on brief, particularly in its water-led composition and rocky enclosure. Softer architectural detailing and less clearly resolved site junctions keep it in the good rather than excellent tier.
An astronaut and a deep-sea diver playing chess together inside a submarine. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 6 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks ninth because strong portrait-style rendering does not fully compensate for weaker subject and setting specificity. The muddled chess detail and competing background activity further reduce its effectiveness.
An astronaut and a deep-sea diver playing chess together inside a submarine. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 4 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks twelfth despite its appealing painting style because it fails to establish both the diver and the submarine setting. Those central prompt failures outweigh its relatively strong composition and surface treatment.
An enchanted bathhouse with glowing lanterns and spirits. Recreate the visual style of 'Spirited Away' by Studio Ghibli, with Miyazaki's ornate architecture and magical atmosphere. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 8th of 10. Its impressive craftsmanship cannot fully compensate for the ambiguous spirit presence and substantial departure from the requested animated-film aesthetic.
An enchanted bathhouse with glowing lanterns and spirits. Recreate the visual style of 'Spirited Away' by Studio Ghibli, with Miyazaki's ornate architecture and magical atmosphere. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 10th of 10. Although technically serviceable, it omits visible spirits and the requested illustrative style, making it the least successful response to this particular brief.
Instagram post graphic: 'SPRING SALE 30% OFF'. Floral background, pastel colors, elegant serif font style visually integrated. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 5th of 13, this combines excellent legibility with unusually rich floral detail. Its heavier typography and crowded ornamentation keep it below the more refined top-ranked designs.
Instagram post graphic: 'SPRING SALE 30% OFF'. Floral background, pastel colors, elegant serif font style visually integrated. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 12th of 13, this has an attractive floral treatment but cannot function as the requested advertisement. Multiple central text failures and the wrong font category substantially outweigh its visual polish.
Two people high-fiving, with focus on their hands meeting mid-air. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 3 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 13th of 13. Its dramatic presentation is outweighed by severe problems with hand scale, contact geometry, and limb continuity—the central requirements of this prompt.
Two people high-fiving, with focus on their hands meeting mid-air. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 11th of 13. Bold styling and expressive poses are strengths, but obscured finger structure makes this less successful as a hand-anatomy study.
A group selfie of three friends of different ethnic backgrounds smiling at the camera. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 5 / 10
Judge's noteRank 13 of 13: the requested subjects are present, but this is the least convincing natural depiction in the set. Its conspicuously rendered faces and restrictive composition outweigh the sharp fabric and hair detail.
A group selfie of three friends of different ethnic backgrounds smiling at the camera. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 8 / 10
Judge's noteRank 6 of 13: this is one of the most naturally textured images and communicates warmth very effectively. Its restrictive crop and less explicit selfie construction keep it behind the top travel and street examples.
A dessert cake that looks like a tiny planet, complete with miniature trees and mountains, photographed in a professional food photography style with tilt-shift focus effect. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 6th of 13 for its imaginative, well-organized miniature scene. Synthetic-looking landscape materials and an ambiguous pastry-versus-planet silhouette limit its realism.
A dessert cake that looks like a tiny planet, complete with miniature trees and mountains, photographed in a professional food photography style with tilt-shift focus effect. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 13th of 13 because it least convincingly presents the requested dessert subject. The missing cake identity outweighs its competent rendering and attractive woodland textures.
A digital clock display showing the time "10:45" in LED-style numerals, photorealistic render. - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 3 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks 13th of 13 because the requested time is fundamentally absent. Strong rendering and visual impact cannot compensate for failure of the central numeric requirement.
A digital clock display showing the time "10:45" in LED-style numerals, photorealistic render. - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 6 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks 9th of 13, with accurate numerals and appealing color but noticeably synthetic construction. It is more successful as a stylized illuminated sign than as a convincing photographic clock render.
A famous cartoon character (e.g. Homer Simpson) rendered fully photorealistically as if a real human being, accurately preserving recognizable facial features and proportions - DALL-E 3
DALL-E 3 2 / 10
Judge's noteRanked eleventh: this misses both a clearly recognizable cartoon identity and the requested photographic style. Surface polish cannot compensate for those two central failures.
A famous cartoon character (e.g. Homer Simpson) rendered fully photorealistically as if a real human being, accurately preserving recognizable facial features and proportions - Midjourney V6.1
Midjourney V6.1 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked seventh: this has impressive rendering detail but a fundamentally nonhuman facial construction. It sits below 1763 because the texture treatment and anatomy diverge more strongly from a live-action human interpretation.

More comparisons