OpenAI
1264 Elo ±37
Rank #3 of 45 · median 126s per image · 12 refused
1–0–0
wins – ties – losses for GPT Image 2
1 direct comparisons
Elo expectation: GPT Image 2 wins 73%
Google
1088 Elo ±36
Rank #15 of 45 · median 16s per image

By category

CategoryGPT Image 2Nano Banana 2Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 1294 1173 —
Architecture & Interiors 1415 1026 —
Complex Scenes 1363 1110 —
Ghibli style 1336 1133 —
Graphic Design 1229 1064 —
Hands & Anatomy 1120 1051 —
Photorealistic People & Portraits 1296 1040 1–0–0
Surreal & Creative Prompts 1330 1143 —
Text in Images 1217 1138 —
Ultra Hard 1319 1084 —

By criterion

CriterionGPT Image 2Nano Banana 2
Prompt adherence 1216 1093
Technical quality 1209 1055
Artistic merit 1161 1074
Detail execution 1240 1093
Realism & coherence 1211 1048

Side by side

A magical girl character in a frilly dress, casting a spell (classic anime trope). - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks fourth as a highly accomplished and strongly adherent magical-girl illustration. Slightly strained hand proportions and dense visual layering place it just behind the leading images.
A magical girl character in a frilly dress, casting a spell (classic anime trope). - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 7 / 10
Judge's noteSixth overall, this is an energetic and fully on-theme illustration. It falls behind the more controlled entries because decorative density and ambiguous overlaps weaken visual hierarchy.
An ancient Roman bathhouse interior with accurate architectural details - marble columns, mosaic floors, arched ceilings, and steam rising from pools. Natural light from oculus openings. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteA visually powerful and strongly prompt-aligned reconstruction with excellent atmosphere. Its smaller figures and some spatial ambiguities are less accomplished than its monumental architecture.
An ancient Roman bathhouse interior with accurate architectural details - marble columns, mosaic floors, arched ceilings, and steam rising from pools. Natural light from oculus openings. - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 9th of 13 because its strong architectural composition is undermined by inconsistent figure execution. It is visually engaging, but less dependable at close inspection than the images ranked above it.
A family cooking together in a kitchen, each person busy with a different task. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 6 / 10
Judge's noteThis is a good conceptual match with four readable jobs, but its interaction details are less assured than its polished appearance initially suggests. Stiff gestures and competing foreground props keep it below the leading images.
A family cooking together in a kitchen, each person busy with a different task. - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 2nd of 13 for its unusually convincing family interaction and successful organization of five activity areas. Only the toddler's slightly ambiguous cooking role and a few small contact details keep it behind the best image.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 3rd of 12, this is one of the strongest interpretations of shared gardening and affectionate supervision. It falls just below the leaders because its tonal separation and focal refinement are slightly less polished.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 5th of 13: excellent emotional storytelling and environmental detail make this one of the stronger results. Minor contact compression and its more uniformly graphic finish keep it behind the most atmospheric entries.
Abstract geometric logo for tech startup 'Quantum Leap', evoking connection & speed, vibrant blue/purple gradient, sharp angles. 'Quantum Leap' as text contained in logo. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 1st of 12, this offers the strongest balance of prompt accuracy, readability, motion, and connectivity. Its controlled geometry and integrated wordmark make it the most convincing finished logo in the set.
Abstract geometric logo for tech startup 'Quantum Leap', evoking connection & speed, vibrant blue/purple gradient, sharp angles. 'Quantum Leap' as text contained in logo. - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 9th of 13: this is technically competent and visually energetic. Its excessive ornamentation and weaker conceptual clarity make it less useful than the cleaner or more explicitly connected designs.
A hand drawing a sketch on paper with a pencil, the hand and pencil tip in clear focus. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanked last because the apparent extra finger critically undermines a prompt centered on convincing finger positioning and object interaction. Attractive materials and a competent sketch cannot compensate for that anatomical failure.
A hand drawing a sketch on paper with a pencil, the hand and pencil tip in clear focus. - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 3rd of 13 for its excellent focus, natural anatomy, and expressive composition. It is close to the leading landscapes and botanical study, but their material rendering is slightly more refined.
A ultra high-resolution portrait of an elderly woman with silver hair and bifocal glasses, each lens reflecting a distant landscape, captured in warm late-afternoon sunlight - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 2nd of 12, this is among the most photographically convincing images in the set. It narrowly trails the leader because its landscape reflections are less clear and visually distinctive.
A ultra high-resolution portrait of an elderly woman with silver hair and bifocal glasses, each lens reflecting a distant landscape, captured in warm late-afternoon sunlight - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 7 / 10
Judge's noteRank 5 of 13: exceptional naturalism and expressive composition make this a strong portrait. Under-specified bifocal construction and small landscape reflections keep its task-specific performance below the leading images.
An armchair designed in the shape of an avocado, presented in a contemporary product photography style with professional studio lighting against a minimalist background. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks 3rd of 12 through clear prompt fulfillment and a coherent, comfortable-looking design. It falls short of the leaders mainly in material nuance and visual distinctiveness rather than any major error.
An armchair designed in the shape of an avocado, presented in a contemporary product photography style with professional studio lighting against a minimalist background. - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks eighth of 13, with stronger photographic execution than conceptual integration. The relatively generic chair shape and rigid seed ornament are the principal limitations.
A birthday cake with icing that spells "Happy Birthday Tim!" on top, food photography style. - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 6th of 12 for excellent text readability and clean photographic presentation. Slightly repetitive decoration and less distinctive styling prevent it from matching the leaders.
A birthday cake with icing that spells "Happy Birthday Tim!" on top, food photography style. - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 10 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 1st of 13, this combines accurate icing text with the strongest atmosphere and photographic realism. Its detailed food styling and disciplined composition warrant the top score.
A famous cartoon character (e.g. Homer Simpson) rendered fully photorealistically as if a real human being, accurately preserving recognizable facial features and proportions - GPT Image 2
GPT Image 2 8 / 10
Judge's noteThis is one of the stronger combinations of recognizable cartoon geometry and human surface detail. The conspicuously constructed eye area keeps it below the best-balanced interpretation.
A famous cartoon character (e.g. Homer Simpson) rendered fully photorealistically as if a real human being, accurately preserving recognizable facial features and proportions - Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanks eighth despite strong photographic execution because the character-specific transformation is largely absent. A convincing portrait of an ordinary man does not adequately satisfy the primary subject requirement.

More comparisons