OpenAI
1222 Elo ±37
Rank #7 of 45 · median 65s per image · 4 refused
48–20–34
wins – ties – losses for GPT Image 2.5 Flare
102 direct comparisons
Elo expectation: GPT Image 2.5 Flare wins 53%
Google
1199 Elo ±39
Rank #9 of 45 · median 22s per image · 1 refused

By category

CategoryGPT Image 2.5 FlareNano Banana 2.1Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 1023 1294 0–4–3
Architecture & Interiors 1370 1303 5–2–3
Complex Scenes 1230 1194 6–2–2
Ghibli style 1315 1211 6–2–1
Graphic Design 1258 1203 7–2–7
Hands & Anatomy 1137 1251 3–2–5
Photorealistic People & Portraits 1114 1166 4–2–4
Surreal & Creative Prompts 1286 1200 5–3–2
Text in Images 1285 1067 6–0–4
Ultra Hard 1338 1270 6–1–3

By criterion

CriterionGPT Image 2.5 FlareNano Banana 2.1
Prompt adherence 1207 1157
Technical quality 1146 1130
Artistic merit 1108 1157
Detail execution 1189 1156
Realism & coherence 1164 1138

Side by side

A cartoon of a cat and a dog on an adventure, drawn in a colorful 2D style. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 6 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks 9th of 12 despite its attractive scenery and strong thematic fit. The prominent foreleg and paw overlap weaken the central character construction enough to outweigh much of the background polish.
A cartoon of a cat and a dog on an adventure, drawn in a colorful 2D style. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 9 / 10
Judge's noteOne of the strongest entries, this combines expressive characters with unusually cohesive environmental design. Its excellent composition and distinctive 2D styling outweigh a few very minor drawing simplifications.
An ancient Roman bathhouse interior with accurate architectural details - marble columns, mosaic floors, arched ceilings, and steam rising from pools. Natural light from oculus openings. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 8 / 10
Judge's noteOne of the strongest empty-interior images, with excellent atmosphere and material execution. Minor historical ambiguity in the fittings and softer secondary details keep it below the leading reconstructions.
An ancient Roman bathhouse interior with accurate architectural details - marble columns, mosaic floors, arched ceilings, and steam rising from pools. Natural light from oculus openings. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 6 / 10
Judge's noteThe bathhouse itself is attractive and substantially fulfills the prompt. Uneven figure realism repeatedly draws attention away from the architecture and lowers the overall result.
An underwater scene with scuba divers exploring a coral reef alongside colorful fish and a sunken ship. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks eighth of 12 as a coherent but comparatively conventional interpretation. Its believable diver poses are offset by weaker tonal separation, intrusive cropping, and less differentiated wreck detail.
An underwater scene with scuba divers exploring a coral reef alongside colorful fish and a sunken ship. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked third of twelve, this stands out for cinematic lighting and an exceptionally strong environmental composition. Slightly ambiguous diver overlaps place it behind the two leading images.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 5th, this is a polished and stylistically convincing realization with excellent plant illustration. Slight congestion around the hands and pumpkin stem prevents the action from achieving the clarity of the top-ranked scene.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 9th of 12, this is charming and richly furnished but less convincing in style fidelity and plant structure. Its decorative abundance does not fully compensate for the weaker botanical and compositional clarity.
The word 'GROWTH' visualized using stylized plant vines organically forming the letters, green tones, white background, graphic design. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 8th of 12, with convincing botanical material but comparatively weak typographic organization. Crowding and uneven letter weight outweigh its solid surface rendering.
The word 'GROWTH' visualized using stylized plant vines organically forming the letters, green tones, white background, graphic design. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 2nd of 12 for its particularly strong integration of organic growth and readable typography. It falls just behind the leader because some crowded braids and flourishes are less precisely separated.
Two people high-fiving, with focus on their hands meeting mid-air. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 11th of 12, this satisfies the scene description but falls short on the task's anatomical emphasis. The conspicuously elongated hands are too prominent to treat as minor imperfections.
Two people high-fiving, with focus on their hands meeting mid-air. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 3rd of 12, this combines strong hand emphasis with convincing social energy. Minor overlap ambiguity and bright highlights are its main limitations.
A hyper-realistic photo of a toddler with curly hair and big eyes, looking upward. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 6 / 10
Judge's noteThe subject and expression satisfy the prompt, but texture quality is a substantial comparative weakness. Its flatter presentation and uneven fine-detail rendering place it in the lower tier of this set.
A hyper-realistic photo of a toddler with curly hair and big eyes, looking upward. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 10 / 10
Judge's noteRanks first for its combination of photographic authenticity, expressive eyes, and carefully resolved textures. It is the most complete response to the prompt, with no conspicuous generation artifacts.
A city skyline that forms the shape of musical notes on a staff, created in a stylized graphic design aesthetic with clean architectural lines and dramatic twilight colors. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 8th of 12, with attractive atmosphere and some genuine tower-to-note interpretation. Its main limitation is the split between the floating musical architecture and the independent skyline below.
A city skyline that forms the shape of musical notes on a staff, created in a stylized graphic design aesthetic with clean architectural lines and dramatic twilight colors. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 2nd of 12 for its exceptional symbolic integration and distinctive graphic design. It narrowly trails the leading image because its crowded infrastructure makes the musical arrangement less immediately legible.
A movie poster for a fictional film titled "The Last Sunrise". Dramatic Hollywood design style. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks third because of its excellent title readability, restrained palette, and convincing portrait work. Only minor supporting-text limitations keep it from matching the two most complete designs.
A movie poster for a fictional film titled "The Last Sunrise". Dramatic Hollywood design style. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 5 / 10
Judge's noteThe poster has immediate blockbuster impact and gets the primary title right. Garbled billing, artificial facial surfaces, and an overloaded central effect make it the least consistently executed image in the set.
Vintage Apple II computer with green monochrome CRT screen, displaying 'END OF WORLD PROCEDURES' in green text. Two external floppy drives stacked on the right, labeled disk II with rainbow Apple logos. Beige casing, black background, retro aesthetic. - GPT Image 2.5 Flare
GPT Image 2.5 Flare 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks seventh of 11, with solid object coverage and a clearly executed screen. Its synthetic surfaces, less assured grounding, and modest fine-detail fidelity limit the overall result.
Vintage Apple II computer with green monochrome CRT screen, displaying 'END OF WORLD PROCEDURES' in green text. Two external floppy drives stacked on the right, labeled disk II with rainbow Apple logos. Beige casing, black background, retro aesthetic. - Nano Banana 2.1
Nano Banana 2.1 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 3rd, with the strongest photographic atmosphere and a highly convincing retro setting. Its looser interpretation of the minimal brief and less exact small lettering place it behind the two most precise hardware portraits.

More comparisons