OpenAI
951 Elo ±46
Rank #27 of 45 · median 5s per image · 11 refused
Not judged in the same call yet
Elo expectation: ChatGPT 4o wins 51%
Black Forest Labs
941 Elo ±51
Rank #28 of 45 · median 24s per image · 1 refused

By category

CategoryChatGPT 4oFlux 2 ProDirect record
Anime & Cartoon Style 764 1012 —
Architecture & Interiors 876 940 —
Complex Scenes 985 960 —
Ghibli style 774 1000 —
Graphic Design 1084 872 —
Hands & Anatomy 909 855 —
Photorealistic People & Portraits 1049 919 —
Surreal & Creative Prompts 886 957 —
Text in Images 1006 963 —
Ultra Hard 961 934 —

By criterion

CriterionChatGPT 4oFlux 2 Pro
Prompt adherence 999 966
Technical quality 942 940
Artistic merit 887 972
Detail execution 904 956
Realism & coherence 975 938

Side by side

A 90s anime-style space battle scene with giant starships and laser beams. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 6 / 10
Judge's noteSixth overall, with competent stylization, recognizable large ships, and clear colored weapons. Flat lighting and limited interaction keep it below the richer, more convincing battle scenes.
A 90s anime-style space battle scene with giant starships and laser beams. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks second of twelve for its exceptional combination of scale, retro styling, intricate spacecraft, and immersive battle depth. Minor congestion in the central beam convergence keeps it just behind the most structurally readable entry.
Photorealistic rendering of a contemporary glass skybridge between two skyscrapers, seen from inside with city views visible through glass walls and floor. Show accurate reflections and structural details. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 12th of 13 because the requested transparent, city-revealing floor is not convincingly achieved. Competent perspective and plausible steelwork cannot compensate for that central prompt omission.
Photorealistic rendering of a contemporary glass skybridge between two skyscrapers, seen from inside with city views visible through glass walls and floor. Show accurate reflections and structural details. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 8 / 10
Judge's noteRank 3 of 12: a strong interpretation with excellent transparency and engineering detail. Slightly congested reflective layering prevents it from matching the photographic clarity of the top two.
A bustling market scene with dozens of people buying and selling goods. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 8 / 10
Judge's noteThis is the strongest illustrated entry and one of the most stylistically coherent images. Repetitive figure design and compressed staging prevent it from matching the best entries' interaction clarity.
A bustling market scene with dozens of people buying and selling goods. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks eighth, with appealing atmosphere and more visible commerce than the lowest-ranked images. Imprecise hand-object interactions prevent its rich presentation from becoming fully convincing.
A countryside train station with a cat waiting on a bench. Rendered in Studio Ghibli animation style with Miyazaki's watercolor backgrounds and hand-drawn quality. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 6 / 10
Judge's noteRank 8 of 11: this is a pleasing, coherent watercolor interpretation that includes the essential subjects. Its generic character design and comparatively simple environmental staging keep it below the more distinctive animation-oriented scenes.
A countryside train station with a cat waiting on a bench. Rendered in Studio Ghibli animation style with Miyazaki's watercolor backgrounds and hand-drawn quality. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 8 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks fifth, distinguished by its atmospheric watercolor treatment and unusually sensitive environmental detail. Its subdued focal contrast and less expressive presentation of the cat reduce its effectiveness as a complete response to the character-centered prompt.
Abstract background graphic, cyberpunk aesthetic, neon pink/blue light trails on dark grid, sense of digital speed, for desktop wallpaper. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 2nd of 13, this is the cleanest and most desktop-ready interpretation. It narrowly trails the winner because its visual vocabulary is simpler and less distinctive.
Abstract background graphic, cyberpunk aesthetic, neon pink/blue light trails on dark grid, sense of digital speed, for desktop wallpaper. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanks twelfth of 12 because pervasive softness and washed-out contrast undermine the intended crisp neon wallpaper effect. It retains the basic motif, but execution is substantially weaker than the other images.
A realistic photo of a hand holding a red apple, with all fingers clearly visible. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 10th of 13 despite competent photographic execution. The failure to clearly display every finger substantially limits its success on the prompt's central requirement.
A realistic photo of a hand holding a red apple, with all fingers clearly visible. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked third of 12, this is one of the strongest results for complete finger visibility and natural anatomy. Slight softness and a comparatively plain presentation keep it below the two leading images.
A studio headshot of a young man with one blue eye and one green eye (heterochromia). - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 10 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 2nd of 13, this is an exceptionally convincing professional headshot with no conspicuous generation artifacts. Its greatest strength is rendering the requested trait clearly while preserving completely believable eye coloration.
A studio headshot of a young man with one blue eye and one green eye (heterochromia). - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 12th, this makes the requested colors unmistakable but renders them least convincingly as a natural physical trait. Overprocessed texture and conspicuously artificial irises outweigh the otherwise competent portrait anatomy.
A steampunk robot time-traveling in ancient Rome, depicted in a detailed cinematic style that blends historical accuracy with copper and brass retrofuturistic aesthetics. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 9th of 13 as an attractive monumental illustration with an incomplete time-travel narrative. Its painterly treatment is legitimate, but its subdued separation and less precise secondary details limit comparative quality.
A steampunk robot time-traveling in ancient Rome, depicted in a detailed cinematic style that blends historical accuracy with copper and brass retrofuturistic aesthetics. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 2nd of 12: it combines strong cinematic storytelling with a particularly convincing steampunk machine and a visible arrival effect. Mechanical congestion and the ruin-heavy historical presentation keep it below the best image.
A technology magazine cover featuring the headline "Tech Innovations of 2025," clean modern design style. - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 8 / 10
Judge's noteThis is the strongest minimalist interpretation and an excellent result for typography precision. Its conservative visual concept places it slightly below the more distinctive robot-led covers.
A technology magazine cover featuring the headline "Tech Innovations of 2025," clean modern design style. - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 4 / 10
Judge's noteRank 11 of 12: competent visual rendering cannot overcome pervasive typography failure. It retains the requested main headline, but falls well short of a credible, readable magazine cover.
Photorealistic close-up portrait of a person clearly performing the American Sign Language gesture for "thank you," hand positioned visibly in front of the chest, clear expression on face, neutral background - ChatGPT 4o
ChatGPT 4o 8 / 10
Judge's noteThis is one of the clearest and most anatomically reliable depictions of the requested starting pose. It ranks third because its presentation is less compelling than the warmer leading portraits.
Photorealistic close-up portrait of a person clearly performing the American Sign Language gesture for "thank you," hand positioned visibly in front of the chest, clear expression on face, neutral background - Flux 2 Pro
Flux 2 Pro 3 / 10
Judge's noteRank 11 of 12: excellent facial detail is outweighed by an incorrect gesture and conspicuously awkward hand construction. It exceeds the six-digit image but is less coherent than the simple open-palm portraits.

More comparisons