A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Top score
9 / 10

This is the strongest all-around image, combining convincing hands with excellent expressions and photographic coherence. It falls short of a flawless score only because some lower hand layers remain occluded and the composition uses a central stack.

All results, ranked

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 9
  • Detail execution 9
  • Realism & coherence 9

Five smiling adults look up at the overhead camera while stacking their hands together on a paved outdoor surface.

This is the strongest all-around image, combining convincing hands with excellent expressions and photographic coherence. It falls short of a flawless score only because some lower hand layers remain occluded and the composition uses a central stack.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Black Forest Labs FLUX 3 Image
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 10
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 8

Five adults, including a white-haired participant, hold hands in a complete circle on a lawn.

This is one of the two strongest images and the clearest literal realization of the prompt. Its readable hand pairs and complete circular composition outweigh the minor softness in small details.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI GPT Image 2
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 8

Five casually dressed adults stand on gray paving, viewed overhead as they stack one hand each at the center.

This is one of the stronger results because it combines the correct count and viewpoint with a comparatively readable hand interaction. Its main limitations are the conventional presentation and slight congestion beneath the top hand.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Reve 2.1
4

Reve 2.1

8 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 7

Five people in neutral and blue clothing stand in a tight overhead circle, placing multiple hands into a central pile.

Ranked fourth, with excellent overhead geometry and an unmistakable five-person group. Its crowded hand pile and restrained visual character make it slightly weaker than the top three.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - MiniMax-H3-Image
5

MiniMax-H3-Image

8 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 10
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 7

Five adults hold hands in a circle on a wooden deck around a basket containing mugs, greenery, and printed material.

This is a strong literal response with an attractive setting and excellent compositional clarity. Its noticeably less natural finger shapes keep it below the two leading images.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Reve Image (Halfmoon)
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 10
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 7

Five people in brightly colored clothing hold hands in a ring on a pale wooden floor.

This is one of the clearest and most faithful interpretations of the prompt. Slightly simplified contact anatomy places it below the strongest image despite its excellent composition.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 7

Five smiling adults look upward from a circle on a tiled floor while joining their hands in a central pile.

This is an appealing, largely compliant group image with strong expressions and composition. Its less precise execution of the central hands keeps it below the best results.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Google Nano Banana 2.1
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 10
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 7

Five adults stand on grass in an open circle, holding the hands of their immediate neighbors.

Excellent literal adherence makes this a successful response to the prompt. Noticeably less natural finger articulation prevents it from reaching the quality of the strongest open-circle example.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Google Nano Banana 2
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 6

Five people hold hands in a circular arrangement on a mossy stone path surrounded by woodland greenery.

Ranked fifth for presenting the requested five-person circle in an attractive, well-rendered environment. A conspicuous ambiguity in the upper hands prevents it from reaching the strongest tier.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - XAI Grok Imagine
10

XAI Grok Imagine

7 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 8
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 6

Five adults in a sunlit grassy setting, seen from an elevated angle, bringing their hands together around a small central opening.

Ranked 6th of 13: this is an attractive and mostly faithful five-person composition. The ambiguous central gesture prevents it from matching the strongest depictions of realistic joined hands.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Google Imagen 4.0 Ultra
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 8
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 7

Five adults stand in a circle on green grass and place their hands together in a central stack.

This is a competent five-person overhead scene with a readable cooperative gesture. Its crowded hand stack and ordinary presentation keep it below the sharper, more convincing examples.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Recraft V4.1
12

Recraft V4.1

7 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 8
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 7

Five fashionably dressed people form a hand-linked circle on sunlit concrete with long cast shadows.

The correct count and attractive overhead arrangement make this a strong interpretation. An unclear link and minor hand simplifications prevent it from joining the leading images.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

Five adults in cream, green, navy, burgundy, and light blue lean toward a central hand stack on a pale concrete floor.

Ranked 8th of 12, this has attractive surface rendering and a recognizable five-person huddle. Its central hand articulation is noticeably weaker than its faces and clothing, limiting the overall result.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - XAI Grok Imagine 2.0
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

Five adults on a broad gray concrete surface reach both hands into a compact central stack, viewed from above.

This meets the basic composition well but is less successful at the detailed hand interaction than its clean presentation initially suggests. Its restrained visual impact and crowded central anatomy place it in the middle tier.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Meta Muse Image
15

Meta Muse Image

6 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 10
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

Five casually dressed adults gather closely on grass, holding hands in a compact circle viewed from overhead.

Ranked 7th of 12, this is compositionally faithful and personable. Noticeable grip irregularities and crowded framing reduce its success despite the correct circular arrangement.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI GPT Image 2.5 Flare
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

Five adults in green, cream, denim, black, and burgundy clothing gather around a central hand stack on a gray floor.

Ranked 9th of 12, this satisfies the broad composition but has a comparatively unconvincing central interaction. Its good surface rendering cannot fully compensate for the compressed hand anatomy.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Alibaba Qwen-Image-3.0-Pro
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 9
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 9
  • Detail execution 5
  • Realism & coherence 4

Five adults gather around a central hand stack at an autumn picnic, surrounded by a basket, blanket, shoes, bottle, and other belongings.

This is among the most attractive images artistically, but its central anatomical weakness must weigh heavily. Beautiful setting and textures cannot compensate fully for an unconvincing depiction of the joined hands.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Microsoft MAI-Image-2.6
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 8
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

Five adults on a dark outdoor path join hands across a crisscrossed arrangement of arms, with ivy around the frame.

The correct count and overhead presentation keep this recognizable and substantially on task. Its complicated connections and weaker hand definition place it below the clearer circular arrangements.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Bytedance Seedream 5.0 Pro
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 8

Six people hold hands around a picnic table and blanket in a sunny meadow, viewed from an elevated angle.

Ranked 8th of 12. Its attractive and coherent execution cannot compensate for adding a sixth participant to a prompt that explicitly requests five.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - XAI Grok Imagine (Quality)
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 8

Six people in colorful casual clothing hold neighboring hands in a closed circle, viewed directly overhead on pale concrete.

Ranked tenth despite excellent visual finish because the six-person count misses an explicit requirement. It is the strongest incorrect-size group, but less faithful than the five-person alternatives above it.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Bytedance Seedream 4.0
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 8

Five people viewed from above, each gripping a large wooden ring with both hands over golden outdoor ground.

Ranked 7th of 13: technically, this is among the strongest images in the set. Its score is substantially reduced because gripping a shared hoop does not fulfill the central requirement of joining hands.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI ChatGPT 4o
22

OpenAI ChatGPT 4o

6 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 6
  • Technical quality 9
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 7

An overhead close-up shows overlapping hands and converging forearms, with cropped shirts, trousers, and shoes around the edges.

Ranked eighth, mainly for its convincing foreground hand and polished photographic rendering. The tight crop and ambiguous complete-group arrangement hold it below more faithful interpretations.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Bytedance Seedream 4.5
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 8

A colorful overhead cartoon of six people holding hands in a complete circle, with warm sunlight and long diagonal shadows.

This is a polished and appealing interpretation with a particularly clear circular structure. The incorrect number of people prevents its strong execution from earning a higher overall score.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Recraft V3
24

Recraft V3

6 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 6
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 5

Five people stand on a paved path bordered by grass, combining a central hand pile with a raised clasp and a hand near another participant's hair.

Ranked ninth, with the correct group size and viewpoint but an inconsistent hand-joining pattern. It is visually competent, yet its central interaction is substantially weaker than the best five-person scenes.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Midjourney V6.1
25

Midjourney V6.1

6 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 9
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 5

An impasto-style overhead painting of six people reaching into a shared hand pile on sunlit, textured ground.

Ranked 8th of 13: exceptional stylistic appeal lifts this above several more literal but weaker images. The wrong participant count and unresolved central hands prevent a higher overall rating.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Krea 2 Large
26

Krea 2 Large

6 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 7

A tightly framed, high-angle photograph of five people in muted casual clothing stacking multiple hands over a textured concrete floor.

This is a well-rendered image of a different group gesture. Its technical strengths cannot fully offset replacing the requested connected circle with a tightly cropped hand stack.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Midjourney v7
27

Midjourney v7

6 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 7

Four people in coats place their hands together while standing on a debris-covered surface, seen directly from overhead.

This is a competent and largely believable overhead photograph. The missing fifth person and less literal hand arrangement keep it below the stronger prompt-matching images.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Google Nano Banana 2 Lite
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 6

Five people in a park extend fists and clasp hands in separate clusters beneath an elevated camera.

This is a competent park portrait but an unsuccessful depiction of the requested shared hand circle. The missing continuous linkage is more important than its otherwise attractive photographic qualities.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 Max
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 6
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

An overhead photograph of five adults leaning inward and stacking several hands over a concrete floor, including two similarly dressed bald men.

The correct count and viewpoint give this partial success. However, the substituted hand-stack gesture and conspicuous inconsistencies in the human details keep it below the stronger examples.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Ideogram 4.0 (Quality)
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 6

Nine people form a large circle on grass, joining hands or wrists, with a bag, shoes, and a bottle nearby.

The image succeeds as an overhead gathering, but its participant count substantially misses the prompt. Confusing hand connections further reduce its effectiveness for the specific anatomical challenge.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Google Nano Banana (2.5 Flash)
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 5

Four adults viewed directly overhead in a mosaic courtyard, extending open hands toward several central contact points.

Ranked 9th of 13: the setting and aerial execution are attractive, but two central prompt requirements are weak. The incorrect count and uncertain hand linkage outweigh the high-quality background.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Black Forest Labs Flux 2 Pro
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 7
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

Six adults lean inward over a dense stack of hands on a gray concrete floor.

The incorrect participant count combines with weak execution of the image's principal hand interaction. Its clean photographic presentation cannot fully compensate for those two central shortcomings.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Black Forest Labs Flux 1.1 Pro Ultra
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 5

A tightly cropped overhead view shows numerous hands stacked together above gray paving, surrounded by partial arms and bodies.

Strong surface rendering does not fully compensate for the unclear group count and congested hand arrangement. It is visually competent but only partially resolves the prompt's structural requirements.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Bytedance Seedream 3.0
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 6

Six people hold hands in a broad circle on gray pavement, photographed from an elevated angle.

Ranked eleventh because the wrong group size combines with noticeably weaker clasp anatomy. The readable circle and competent staging do not overcome these central shortcomings.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - MiniMax Image-01
35

MiniMax Image-01

5 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 8
  • Realism & coherence 7

A tight overhead close-up of six interlocking hands and forearms, surrounded by colorful clothing.

This is a visually strong close-up, but the extra participant directly contradicts an explicit requirement. That counting error and the incomplete depiction of the group outweigh its polished surface rendering.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Ideogram V2
36

Ideogram V2

5 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 8
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 5

Six adults gather on reddish desert rocks, reaching inward to stack their hands, viewed from an elevated angle.

An attractive environment and strong color composition make this visually appealing. The extra participant and unresolved central hand anatomy substantially weaken its success on the actual task.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Alibaba Z-Image Turbo
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 5
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 6

An overhead photograph of seven casually dressed people holding hands around an open center on a pale floor, with several participants cropped by the frame.

This is a competent overhead ring composition, but the incorrect participant count is a substantial prompt failure. Its obscured connections and restrained presentation also place it below the best circular arrangements.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Bytedance Seedream 5.5
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 3
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 5
  • Detail execution 7
  • Realism & coherence 8

Six adults stand indoors around a circular rope, gripping it with both hands under direct flash-like lighting.

The image is relatively believable as a scene, but it substitutes a different activity and adds an extra participant. Those substantive prompt failures outweigh its competent anatomical rendering.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI GPT Image 1.5
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 5
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 4
  • Realism & coherence 3

Four people in denim, green, red plaid, and yellow clothing pile their hands together above a wooden deck.

Ranked twelfth because it has only four people and a major hand-ownership problem at the center. Attractive color and sharp fabrics cannot rescue the prompt's primary anatomical interaction.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Google Imagen 3.0
40

Google Imagen 3.0

4 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 5

Six people stand in a loose circle on a lawn, with several joined hands, wrist contacts, and one visibly unjoined hand.

The photograph is superficially competent but misses the requested count and coherent hand-linked structure. These central failures outweigh its pleasant lighting and recognizable figures.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - OpenAI DALL-E 3
41

OpenAI DALL-E 3

4 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 4
  • Realism & coherence 3

Eight seated adults arranged in a tight overhead circle, reaching into a crowded central hand stack.

Ranked 12th of 13: polished peripheral rendering cannot compensate for the wrong count and compromised central anatomy. The hand interaction is a critical weakness rather than merely a small cosmetic flaw.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Google Nano Banana Pro
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 6
  • Technical quality 6
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 3
  • Realism & coherence 3

An overhead close-up shows five cropped adults grasping wrists in a loop above leaf-strewn cobblestones.

Ranked 12th of 12. Despite polished textures and the correct general viewpoint, the anatomically incoherent hand chain is a critical failure of the prompt's main challenge.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 2
  • Technical quality 7
  • Artistic merit 8
  • Detail execution 6
  • Realism & coherence 4

Six adults in white clothing hold hands around a camera looking upward toward a blue sky above a beach.

Despite its visual impact, this is the weakest response to the actual prompt because both participant count and camera direction are wrong. Unresolved hand connections further limit its success.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - Black Forest Labs FLUX.1 Kontext Max
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 4
  • Technical quality 5
  • Artistic merit 4
  • Detail execution 3
  • Realism & coherence 2

A close overhead view of numerous sleeved arms and distorted hands forming an open ring over grass.

Ranked 13th of 13: this is the weakest result because the primary hand interaction contains severe anatomical failures. Clear fabric and grass textures cannot rescue the malformed contact ring or establish the requested five-person group.

A group of five people joining hands in a circle, seen from above - XAI Grok 2 Image
45

XAI Grok 2 Image

3 / 10
Critique
  • Prompt adherence 2
  • Technical quality 6
  • Artistic merit 6
  • Detail execution 4
  • Realism & coherence 3

A close, sunlit photograph of seven smiling people gathered around overlapping hands, with an older woman partially visible in the foreground.

This is the weakest match because it misses the participant count, overhead viewpoint, and connected-circle structure. Attractive expressions cannot compensate for those departures and the conspicuous hand problems.

Compare this prompt's top models

More Hands & Anatomy prompts