Ideogram
773 Elo ±51
Rank #39 of 45 · median 21s per image
Not judged in the same call yet
Elo expectation: Ideogram V2 wins 48%
Minimax
790 Elo ±46
Rank #38 of 45 · median 36s per image

By category

CategoryIdeogram V2MiniMax Image-01Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 740 702 —
Architecture & Interiors 632 741 —
Complex Scenes 681 716 —
Ghibli style 453 732 —
Graphic Design 846 770 —
Hands & Anatomy 960 834 —
Photorealistic People & Portraits 912 788 —
Surreal & Creative Prompts 667 702 —
Text in Images 902 861 —
Ultra Hard 542 865 —

By criterion

CriterionIdeogram V2MiniMax Image-01
Prompt adherence 823 777
Technical quality 830 865
Artistic merit 772 967
Detail execution 805 814
Realism & coherence 824 864

Side by side

An anime-style portrait of a samurai standing under pink cherry blossoms. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanks 12th of 12 because visible hand problems and inconsistent rendering substantially detract from the image. Correct subject matter cannot compensate for its weaker anatomy and equipment coherence.
An anime-style portrait of a samurai standing under pink cherry blossoms. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 6 / 10
Judge's noteRank 12 of 12: technically accomplished, but the weakest match to the requested combination of anime styling and samurai identity. Its rendering polish does not fully compensate for that central stylistic mismatch.
Isometric architectural illustration of an ancient Chinese temple complex showing multiple pavilions, gardens, and ceremonial spaces. Include proper roof structures and traditional ornamentation. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 7th of 13, this image benefits from strong roof drawing and an attractive painterly finish. The cropped site and ambiguous terrace connections prevent it from matching the clearer architectural overviews.
Isometric architectural illustration of an ancient Chinese temple complex showing multiple pavilions, gardens, and ceremonial spaces. Include proper roof structures and traditional ornamentation. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 11th of 12, this is visually appealing but architecturally imprecise. Its malformed access details and weaker adherence to the requested illustration format outweigh the attractive lighting.
A misty dawn at an African savanna watering hole where elephants, lions, and zebras coexist in tense harmony, with a crocodile partially submerged in the foreground and flamingos taking flight in the background, golden hour lighting. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 6 / 10
Judge's noteRank 10 of 13: This image is technically stronger than its placement alone suggests, with coherent lighting and reflections. Missing lions substantially reduce its success against the actual prompt despite its otherwise appealing execution.
A misty dawn at an African savanna watering hole where elephants, lions, and zebras coexist in tense harmony, with a crocodile partially submerged in the foreground and flamingos taking flight in the background, golden hour lighting. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 4 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks 12th because the central animal interaction is the least anatomically legible in the set. Attractive haze and reflections cannot compensate for the confused zebra-lion grouping and weak species definition.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 4 / 10
Judge's noteThe weakest image in the set, despite including the basic subjects. Unclear central interaction, inconsistent vegetable morphology, and underdeveloped environmental detail collectively reduce its effectiveness.
A child and elder tending oversized vegetables in a garden. Reproduce the artistic style of Studio Ghibli, with their distinctive character proportions and detailed plant illustrations. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 10th of 12, this image succeeds primarily through atmosphere and character appeal. Its weaker style match and confusing vegetable growth prevent it from matching the more grounded garden illustrations.
Seamless geometric pattern, Art Deco style, gold lines on deep emerald green background, high resolution texture for print. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 9 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks 2nd of 13 because its repeat structure and line discipline are exceptionally strong. It narrowly trails the winner in palette richness and ornamental character.
Seamless geometric pattern, Art Deco style, gold lines on deep emerald green background, high resolution texture for print. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 4 / 10
Judge's noteRanks twelfth because uncontrolled texture and fragmented ornament undermine an otherwise recognizable repeating design. It meets the basic palette requirement but needs substantial cleanup and stylistic refinement.
A realistic photo of a hand holding a red apple, with all fingers clearly visible. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks second, with excellent adherence and some of the strongest tactile detail in the set. The slightly crowded framing and dominant apple reflection make it marginally less refined than the leading image.
A realistic photo of a hand holding a red apple, with all fingers clearly visible. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 3 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 12th of 12 because the hand structure fails the task's central anatomical requirement. Attractive lighting and fruit texture cannot outweigh the apparent extra-digit or second-hand ambiguity.
A professional headshot of a businesswoman wearing glasses, against a blurred background. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked second, with excellent material detail and one of the most natural-looking faces in the set. Slightly stronger background structure makes it marginally less controlled than the leading image.
A professional headshot of a businesswoman wearing glasses, against a blurred background. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked eighth, this offers attractive styling but a less natural photographic finish. Its beauty-retouched complexion and obscured hair detail outweigh the strengths of its color and composition.
A forest of giant mushrooms with houses built on top of them, rendered in a whimsical Studio Ghibli-inspired art style with vibrant colors and fantastical details. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanks seventh for its distinctive illustration style and clear fulfillment of the cap-top housing concept. Architectural distortion and crowded object boundaries keep it below the more coherent images.
A forest of giant mushrooms with houses built on top of them, rendered in a whimsical Studio Ghibli-inspired art style with vibrant colors and fantastical details. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 11th of 12 despite attractive lighting and abundant decoration. Its weaker separation between houses and mushrooms, together with the stylistic mismatch, reduces its success on this particular prompt.
A technology magazine cover featuring the headline "Tech Innovations of 2025," clean modern design style. - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 8th of 13, this delivers the exact headline and strong product illustrations. Its incoherent secondary text and relatively generic layout keep it well below the polished editorial covers.
A technology magazine cover featuring the headline "Tech Innovations of 2025," clean modern design style. - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 3 / 10
Judge's noteThis is the weakest result because it fails both the required headline precision and the magazine format. Competent product rendering cannot compensate for those central errors.
Photorealistic daytime street photograph, clearly showing a man standing still on a busy urban street corner holding a rectangular cardboard sign clearly facing camera, handwritten bold black marker text clearly readable as "AGI has arrived!", background blurred with realistic pedestrians and cityscape - Ideogram V2
Ideogram V2 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked eleventh, this preserves the correct message but inadequately presents the man holding it. Its graphic lettering and overwhelming board size represent substantial departures from the intended street portrait.
Photorealistic daytime street photograph, clearly showing a man standing still on a busy urban street corner holding a rectangular cardboard sign clearly facing camera, handwritten bold black marker text clearly readable as "AGI has arrived!", background blurred with realistic pedestrians and cityscape - MiniMax Image-01
MiniMax Image-01 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanks second for its combination of excellent readability, strong photographic execution, and visual impact. Its slightly heightened contrast feels more polished than the most natural-looking entry, but there is no conspicuous central flaw.

More comparisons