Ideogram
809 Elo ±38
Rank #36 of 45 · median 12s per image
29–24–47
wins – ties – losses for Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
100 direct comparisons
Elo expectation: Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) wins 49%
Bytedance
814 Elo ±39
Rank #35 of 45 · median 8s per image

By category

CategoryIdeogram 3.0 (Quality)Seedream 3.0Direct record
Anime & Cartoon Style 790 869 2–4–4
Architecture & Interiors 810 706 4–0–6
Complex Scenes 746 771 2–4–4
Ghibli style 678 914 0–1–9
Graphic Design 948 847 6–1–3
Hands & Anatomy 837 749 4–2–4
Photorealistic People & Portraits 818 858 2–4–4
Surreal & Creative Prompts 667 872 0–5–5
Text in Images 874 736 5–2–3
Ultra Hard 631 650 4–1–5

By criterion

CriterionIdeogram 3.0 (Quality)Seedream 3.0
Prompt adherence 808 879
Technical quality 936 770
Artistic merit 886 820
Detail execution 854 766
Realism & coherence 882 829

Side by side

A cute chibi-style dragon sleeping on a pile of gold. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks twelfth: a competent, cute sticker with excellent immediate readability. It is the least competitive on intricate surface work and environmental richness, which are important differentiators in this set.
A cute chibi-style dragon sleeping on a pile of gold. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 6th for exceptional softness, cuteness, and polished toy-like rendering. It trails the more detailed fantasy illustrations because much of the treasure is obscured by blur and specular glare.
A photorealistic interior of a modern Scandinavian-style living room with natural light streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows. Show detailed wood textures, fabric materials, and proper light reflections. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 9th of 12 despite its strong visual appeal, primarily because it is a less precise stylistic match. Its atmospheric strengths exceed its clarity in the crowded background details.
A photorealistic interior of a modern Scandinavian-style living room with natural light streaming through floor-to-ceiling windows. Show detailed wood textures, fabric materials, and proper light reflections. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 12th of 13, this image combines a key window-height omission with noticeably weaker surface rendering. Its coherent Scandinavian styling prevents it from being a failure, but it does not convincingly meet the material-realism test.
A medieval battlefield with knights on horseback and a dragon flying overhead. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked twelfth of 12. It includes every requested subject, but inconsistent material handling, stiff anatomy, and visually tangled interactions make it the least integrated scene.
A medieval battlefield with knights on horseback and a dragon flying overhead. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 7 / 10
Judge's noteRanked eighth as a competent, cinematic interpretation with strong subject visibility. Specific hoof and riding-equipment issues hold it below the better-integrated battlefield scenes.
A countryside train station with a cat waiting on a bench. Rendered in Studio Ghibli animation style with Miyazaki's watercolor backgrounds and hand-drawn quality. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanked tenth because the attractive rural background is undermined by the unusually schematic central cat. The image remains readable and relevant, but its weak character integration is the most consequential shortcoming in this set.
A countryside train station with a cat waiting on a bench. Rendered in Studio Ghibli animation style with Miyazaki's watercolor backgrounds and hand-drawn quality. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 8 / 10
Judge's noteRank 4 of 11: this is one of the strongest stylistic matches, with an expressive animated cat and convincing rural background painting. Slightly rough structural details keep it below the two most polished station views.
Visual element for an infographic about water conservation. Stylized water droplet icon containing a small green leaf, clean vector art. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 9 / 10
Judge's noteRanked second: one of the most immediately usable infographic elements in the set. Its disciplined construction and excellent readability outweigh its relatively conventional styling.
Visual element for an infographic about water conservation. Stylized water droplet icon containing a small green leaf, clean vector art. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 7th, this communicates water and nature clearly but is less suitable as a reusable infographic element. Its textured, shadow-heavy presentation creates a noticeable gap from the cleaner upper-ranked designs.
Two hands forming a heart shape together against a plain background. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanked 5th of 12, this is one of the most aesthetically distinctive interpretations. Slightly crowded fingertip contacts and softened backlit detail keep it below the clearest anatomical examples.
Two hands forming a heart shape together against a plain background. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks ninth of 13 for a credible, symmetrical silhouette but limited inspectable detail. It communicates the prompt successfully without matching the anatomical clarity of the stronger images.
A bride on her wedding day, smiling with tears of joy in her eyes. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 6 / 10
Judge's noteRank 10 of 12: this is technically one of the cleaner portraits, but it omits the prompt's defining tears-of-joy element. That central omission outweighs its otherwise strong photographic finish.
A bride on her wedding day, smiling with tears of joy in her eyes. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 8 / 10
Judge's noteRanks third because its emotional expression is among the clearest in the set. Slightly processed surface texture keeps it below the most photographically convincing results.
An armchair designed in the shape of an avocado, presented in a contemporary product photography style with professional studio lighting against a minimalist background. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 3 / 10
Judge's noteThis ranks 12th of 12 because the requested armchair is missing, a critical prompt failure. Polished food-object rendering cannot compensate for replacing the primary subject with a literal avocado.
An armchair designed in the shape of an avocado, presented in a contemporary product photography style with professional studio lighting against a minimalist background. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteRanks ninth of 13 for clear fruit recognition but less convincing photographic execution. Softness, uncertain base construction, and ambiguous material transitions hold it back.
A movie poster for a fictional film titled "The Last Sunrise". Dramatic Hollywood design style. - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 8 / 10
Judge's noteAn excellent illustrated alternative with some of the strongest typography in the set. It ranks below the leading designs primarily because its revival-poster aesthetic is a less exact stylistic match to the Hollywood brief.
A movie poster for a fictional film titled "The Last Sunrise". Dramatic Hollywood design style. - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 4 / 10
Judge's noteThis is the weakest entry overall because its retro concept is compromised by malformed supporting typography and unresolved graphic hierarchy. The readable main title prevents total failure, but the result falls well short of a convincing finished Hollywood poster.
Rain-slicked Singapore street, 3 AM. A lone elderly hawker cleans his cart under one flickering fluorescent light. Steam rises gently. Low-angle shot, photorealistic - Ideogram 3.0 (Quality)
Ideogram 3.0 (Quality) 5 / 10
Judge's noteRanks twelfth because it most clearly misses the defining 3 AM atmosphere and leaves the cleaning action ambiguous. Its competent figure rendering and pleasant colors do not resolve those central prompt failures.
Rain-slicked Singapore street, 3 AM. A lone elderly hawker cleans his cart under one flickering fluorescent light. Steam rises gently. Low-angle shot, photorealistic - Seedream 3.0
Seedream 3.0 6 / 10
Judge's noteRank 8 of 13. This is an atmospheric, recognizable hawker scene, but exaggerated steam and uneven fine-detail coherence keep it below the stronger photographic executions.

More comparisons